1. Similarities: The traditional lesson and constructivism lesson are the same because they are both measuring something with some form of measurement and they both had the length of measurement either drawn out on the carpet with tape or had told the students what to measure in the length like 100 feet. So the students did know how long to measure.
Differences: The differences between traditional and constructivism is where the traditional lesson knew exactly what they were using for measurement: a yard stick and the constructivism didn't know exactly what they were using for measurement, they had to find that out for themselves. The traditional lesson, the teacher told the students exactly how they were going to measure, putting the yardstick down (in which they had never used before but were using it anyway) and then moving it to the end of where the first yard stick had ended and do that until they get to 100 feet. The constructivism approach, the students had no idea how to measure, the teacher didn't say, "ok now we will have Tom lie down and measure the inside of the boat". The students were supposed to figure that out on their own.
2. Benefits: The benefits of not telling the students what measurement to use is for them to figure it out on their own so they can learn instead of the teacher telling them and then they wonder why their hands and feet couldn't work as a form of measurement. Another reason, the students were able to come together and work out the problem as a class. They were able to bounce off of each others ideas and figure out that Tom had just been measured 4 feet so that is one way to start to figure out the problem.
Drawbacks: Without telling the students how they are going to measure, it may take a few days rather than just one day to get the lesson done. Another reason, the students may get frustrated because she won't tell them the answer because she wants them to figure it out but she is scaffolding them.
The benefits are worth the cost because the students are using their own schema to figure out the problem. It gives the students an opportunity to work together and try to figure it out as a class. It also gives the students the mental capacity to remember this lesson and maybe never forget it because of the problem solving activity they had to go through to find out that hands and feet don't work ever for measurement because everyone's hands and feet are different sizes.
3. Critical Thinking: The term critical thinking refers to the thought processes used to evaluate information and the practice of using such conclusions to guide behavior. The process of critical thinking is associated with accuracy, logic, depth, fairness, credibility, and intellectual clarity. The word “critical” is not used to imply negativity or pessimism, however. Critical thinking merely means that one must not automatically accept the validity of the information he or she is given.
Constructivism example promotes critical thinking because the students don't know what measurement to use so they are trying to figure out what to use that everyone would know how long that is. They figure out that hands and feet wouldn't work because everyone's hands and feet are different and to one person Tom's feet may mean something different to another person.
Critical thinking examples: When Tom said he was just measured as 4 feet, the students knew that was one measurement that they knew and so they could try and measure the boat with knowing that Tom was 4 feet. They had to "report to the king" to let him know the size of the ship but he wouldn't know how big Mark or Sue's feet an hands would be. So they had to come up with a standard size of what the king and the children would know so they could get an accurate answer so they took Zeb's feet. They made a measurement of it and then used that to measure the boat. The hands and feet approach are inconsistent in size so the students knew they had to find a standard measurement of size that the students and everyone else would know what they are talking about.
4. I think the constructivist activity would be described as an authentic activity because authentic means that students are required to use their thinking to perform tasks that are relevant to life outside of school. I think they had to do that because in school they were learning about measurement and the teacher didn't tell them that they were to use a yard stick to measure the length and width of a boat. The students had to figure that out on their own and so when they were deciding how to measure the boat to tell the king, they realized that the king wouldn't know what size Mark's hands or feet were so they had to find a measurement that is the same to the king and to them. They figured out that the king knew Zed and that they knew Zed so they could use his feet. That is the same thing outside of school. If they were to tell the President how big their classroom was, there is a likelihood that the students and the President won't know the same person to measure their foot, in this case, they would need to use a standard measurement using a yard stick or ruler for that manner for the students and the President and anyone else to recognize how big the classroom is because it is in the same measurement system that everyone knows.
Saturday, March 6, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment